Identify the proposition before reviewing the exhibit
A report can contain accurate transaction records while making an unsupported claim about the person behind them. Start by writing the proposition the exhibit is intended to support: movement of an asset, control of an address, identification of a service, or another defined issue.
Then ask which part of the exhibit supports that proposition and which additional facts are needed. A transaction timestamp may help construct a chronology without proving the sender’s intent. This distinction keeps technical observations from carrying more legal weight than the analysis supports.
Check provenance and the record of handling
Ask where the material came from, when it was obtained and how it was preserved. Retain source records alongside working copies and document transformations such as normalising timestamps, filtering a dataset or redacting a document. A checksum can help identify changes to a file; it does not establish that the original content was true.
NIST’s preservation guidance provides a reference for digital-evidence handling. Public availability of blockchain data does not remove the need to explain the collection and analysis of the material actually relied upon. Off-chain exports, messages and third-party labels need their own provenance.
Reference: NIST: digital evidence preservation
Review the method and its alternatives
Ask for the method behind each important inference, the assumptions it uses and any relevant limitations. A useful explanation addresses alternative interpretations, especially where a service label or address grouping is central to the case.
Consider whether another reviewer could follow the reasoning with the retained materials. If a proprietary tool supplies a conclusion that cannot be fully inspected, record that limitation and discuss what independent support is available. The report should make uncertainty understandable without disguising it as a precise probability.
A well-supported finding can give counsel a clear basis for a disclosure request, a targeted challenge or further expert instructions. The aim of review is to identify what the evidence can usefully support and which gaps need attention.
Read the full explanation: Attribution, ownership and the evidence behind freezing orders.
Check the expert requirements in the forum
Admissibility and expert duties depend on the forum and the nature of the proceedings. In England and Wales, CPR Part 35 provides that an expert’s duty to assist the court overrides obligations to the instructing or paying party; court permission is also relevant to use of expert evidence. Practice Direction 35 addresses report requirements.
Those rules should not be presented as a global certification standard. Ask local counsel which requirements apply and instruct the expert accordingly. Avoid describing a draft as automatically “court-admissible” because it contains a flow chart or was produced by a familiar tool.
For valuations, specify the purpose, asset, time, time zone and price source. If valuation is outside the tracing expert’s remit, identify who will address it rather than treating a dashboard figure as a settled measure.
Reference: England and Wales: Civil Procedure Rules Part 35 · England and Wales: Practice Direction 35
Apply the distinction to an example
Optional knowledge check
What does a recorded file checksum establish?
Read the explanation without answering
A reference for checking whether the file’s bytes have changed. It supports integrity checking, while provenance and substantive accuracy require separate assessment.
Review the points you want to take forward
Your review checklist
0 of 4 steps reviewed. This is a learning checklist, not a safety or recovery score.
Answers stay in this tab and reset on reload. The PDF is a concise reference with a blank checklist.
Explore a related guide
References and further reading
Examples are fictional. Checklists are editorial learning aids and do not assess an individual case.

